“Even his oxygen machine was on beat… as he sang at 80…”
… I think I streamed it… I might even have seen it in a theater. Young@Heart documents a chorus of people in their 80s, singing modern songs. It was supposed to be a duet… but one of the pair dies… The other partner, a man on oxygen, takes the stage and sings Fix You, a song full of pathos before anyone touches it… and he is incredible. A show stopper…
…the plan with 2 names on it…
You have one of these on the board right now. The migration that only works if your 2 senior engineers are both in the room. The launch where one of them knows the database and the other knows the customer. You wrote it as a duet, and you have never asked what happens if one voice goes quiet. Nobody does. It feels like bad luck to say it out loud.
So most leaders find out on the night. Somebody is out, somebody has left, and the one still standing carries both parts without anyone asking whether they can. Tech people rarely say no. They say “I’ve got it,” and then they are up at 2 a.m., carrying the part alone.
…a song written to comfort, and a chorus that sings what it didn’t choose…
Fix You came out of a hard season at home. Chris Martin started it to comfort Gwyneth Paltrow after her father, the director Bruce Paltrow, died, on a keyboard her father had given her that sat unused in the house. “It had these amazing sounds on it,” he said. Coldplay put it on X&Y in 2005, and that year Martin called it “probably the most important song we’ve ever written.”
A year later, in Northampton, Massachusetts, it found a chorus with an average age of about 80. Young@Heart began in 1982, when Bob Cilman turned a lunchtime sing-along at a meal site for the elderly into a group that sings rock and punk. “It’s making these people sing stuff that they really didn’t want to hear their kids listen to,” Cilman said.
Fred Knittle had left the chorus after a heart attack and came back for special performances, living with congestive heart failure. Cilman planned Fix You as a duet, Fred and Bob Salvini. Days before the concert, Salvini died of a heart attack, and Joe Benoit, another member, died too. Fred sat alone on the stage of the Academy of Music, oxygen at his nose, and sang it by himself. He died on January 1, 2009, at 83.
Every plan written for 2 voices has 1 person who will carry it alone. Ask them now, not on the night.
…to manage is to ask before the stage does…
To manage is to get the right information to the right people at the right time. Most of us hear that and think of the status report, the stakeholder map, the steering committee. It is also the quiet conversation with the person who would be left holding the part, held weeks before anyone needs it.
The roadblock is optimism dressed up as a plan. We manage the schedule as if every voice will be there on the night, because asking who carries it alone sounds like we expect the worst. We don’t. We expect Humans. And people get sick, move on, burn out, and sometimes do not come back. Asking early is the most Human thing a plan can hold.
…the film that got there first…
Young@Heart, directed by Stephen Walker, aired on British television in November 2006 and won the audience award at the Los Angeles Film Festival in 2007. Walker followed the chorus for 7 weeks of rehearsals toward 1 concert in Northampton.
The song had its own road. It came out as a single on September 5, 2005, and went to No. 4 in the UK. It is 3 times platinum in the US, and in 2021 Rolling Stone put it at No. 392 of the 500 greatest songs of all time. A song written for one grieving person, carried by a man who was never supposed to sing it alone.
…what the film showed me…
Music never leaves us… voluntarily. You just stop doing it because someone said you were off key, beat, or both. Or you didn’t like the sound of our voice… and the joy of singing drains out of your life…
You will never forget Fred, singing that well with oxygen at his nose. And Bob Cilman, the director, pouring energy into every single rehearsal. And a room of people in their 80s who came alive singing songs they didn’t even like 😉 The contrast was the whole point. And again science documents that even Alzheimer’s patients who can’t talk, CAN sing…
Everything I wanted to do about bringing music back into corporate settings was right there on the screen, as plain as it gets. I still cry through most of the movie… and now use that energy and pathos to drive forward. We will sing together…
Your “Simple… Not Easy” move: Find the 1 part of this month’s plan that rests on 2 people, and tell each of them this week, one at a time, what you would need if they had to carry it alone.
If that conversation shows you a plan with no understudy, let’s manage it together before the night arrives. Schedule time with me here.
Ask before the stage does, and nobody has to sing it alone… Fix You
